Pizza restaurants

Eddies Pizza - Lake Ronkonkoma

4.0 137 reviews 11:00 AM - 09:00 PM 163 Ronkonkoma Ave, Lake Ronkonkoma, NY 11779, United States

Discover this place

Eddies Pizza is a pizza restaurant located at 163 Ronkonkoma Ave in Lake Ronkonkoma, NY. The establishment offers a diverse menu centered around classic and specialty pizzas, including options like Hawaiian, Pepperoni, and signature pies such as Vegetable Eggplant and the Supreme Square. The menu also features traditional Italian dishes like spaghetti with meatballs and various entrees served with a range of sauces, from vodka to Alfredo. Sides such as garlic knots, mozzarella sticks, and fried ravioli complement the main offerings. The atmosphere at Eddies Pizza is casual and inviting, catering to both quick slice-and-soda meals and more relaxed dining experiences. Weekly specials, including the Wednesday Special with a cheese pie and assorted appetizers, add variety for regular guests. With a focus on substantial portions and a broad selection, the restaurant serves as a notable local spot for pizza and Italian comfort food in the Lake Ronkonkoma area.

Photos

Eddies Pizza - Lake Ronkonkoma - Photo 1

Eddies Pizza - Lake Ronkonkoma - Photo 2

Eddies Pizza - Lake Ronkonkoma - Photo 3

Eddies Pizza - Lake Ronkonkoma - Photo 4

Eddies Pizza - Lake Ronkonkoma - Photo 5

Amenities & More

Service options

Delivery
Onsite services
Takeout
Dine-in

Highlights

Serves local specialty

Popular for

Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Dining options

Lunch
Dinner
Catering
Counter service
Dessert
Seating
Table service

Amenities

Restroom

Atmosphere

Casual

Crowd

Family-friendly

Note: Amenity details are aggregated from verified visits, the venue's website and Google. They may change without notice. We recommend confirming key details (pet policy, accessibility, reservations) directly with Eddies Pizza - Lake Ronkonkoma before visiting.

Reviews for Eddies Pizza - Lake Ronkonkoma

4.0

137 reviews

100%

20%

30%

Review highlights

Based on 137 reviews

Eddies Pizza in Lake Ronkonkoma is frequently praised for its consistently fresh and flavorful offerings, with customers highlighting the quality of ingredients such as real sausage and a well-balanced sauce. The restaurant excels in timely service, particularly for takeout orders, and staff are often described as friendly and accommodating, enhancing the overall experience. The menu variety, including standout items like specialty pizzas and unique options such as pinwheels and pasta dishes, receives positive attention. Presentation is valued even in takeout, reflecting a commitment to detail. Special requests, including custom-shaped pizzas, are generally handled with care and flexibility, contributing to strong customer satisfaction. Overall, Eddies Pizza is recognized for its combination of delicious food, reliable service, and attentive customer care within a welcoming atmosphere.

LDA Rodriguez

Jul 07, 2025

We took out a large pie: half pepperoni and sausage, half chicken and mushroom. Really yummy, especially the chicken and mushroom. All came out to 27.00. Twenty-minute wait if you order by phone and pick-up your order. We will return when we are in the area.

Kimathi Witt MBA, MFA, MA

Jun 13, 2025

The employees are amazing. This food is so delicious and so fresh and always ready on time. The best I've had so far.

s mitchell

Jun 12, 2025

This place has the most amazing pinwheels. I love the ham and cheese! On a whim I ordered spaghetti and clam sauce. My husband commented on how good it looked as he took it out of the bag. When I sat down to eat it, it really did look good with the clams arranged nicely on top. Even in take out the presentation counts! And it tasted even better than it looked. It was just a quick last second addition that ended up being the star of our meal. Delicious!!!

ali Rupe

May 28, 2025

I had this pizza today it was served at a get together this pizza was the best pizza I’ve had in years delicious, cheesy , real sausage , sauce !!!

Madeline Wyszomierski

May 05, 2025

They were amazing! I called in the morning and asked if they could make a pizza shaped like the number 4 for my sons birthday. I didn’t plan ahead and did it that day. They made it and were so sweet about it. The pizza was good. I had no complaints, they even asked if I wanted them to trim the edges to make it perfect. Really happy about the customer service!

Donna Dzintarnieks

Apr 30, 2025

Pin wheels were delivered cool, were delicious! Meatball Parm hero was all breading 90% 30 % meat fell apart on hero . Never would order again! Pizza always Good! Delivery quick! This is one of the best Pizza Restaurants in the area. Prices are great! And so are the owners! They have been. Serving the area since before I moved here. In 1987! Stop By...

SOUR-GIRL- 1

Apr 20, 2025

Pizza is always fresh , service fast. My son is picky, and likes their pepperoni a lot. They have generous slice sizes , not like others that are small and paper thin.

Michael Goldberg

Mar 29, 2025

I moved into a cottage in Lake Ronkonkoma last November. I'm a single middle-aged man I don't cook, don't want to cook, don't want to learn. Love pizza. Found Eddie's Pizzeria. Excellent food friendly service reasonable prices and they deliver it to my Cottage. Highly recommend this place